Introduction
Media towers were taller than the towers of the churches and
thereby symbolically replaced the power of infl uencing public faith,
values and attitude to much extent. Institutions such as churches,
schools and families had once been dominant sources of providing
meanings of life and of God [Goethals, 1990] but today the media
compete with these as dominant sources of meanings and provide a
market of meanings from which people buy and borrow meanings
that satisfy them in their changing contexts. The changing contexts
demand people to search for meanings of God and of life. Among the
competing social, cultural and political institutions, media has taken
the central role in communicating these meanings to the public and
enabling them to share through them as well. Engaging in such search
for meanings of life and of God, led media to play the role of a pastor,
theologian, prophet and educator in public and private lives of people.
When the audience construct and negotiate their meanings of God
and of life there begins the dialogue between theology and media.
This book is an attempt to provide a space for dialogue between
theology and media from new directions and especially dialogue
between perspectives from the South and North. It is diffi cult to
address all the issues and questions related to this area within so slim
a book and so inevitably some choices had to be made. This book will
focus on those issues that are often neglected by the media scholars
in relation to religion and also by theological scholars in relation to
media such as imagination, entertainment, representation, freedom
and alternatives. The media have created irreversible contexts where
many new questions arise for theological thinking and studies. The
primary principle of this book is to show that theologians have to take
media seriously in their contextualising hermeneutics and particularly
in addressing some question being raised by people after their
encounter with media. Hermeneutics involves developing meanings
John Joshva Raja
6
of those narratives about God and about life in the universe. These
meanings were once provided by the church, family and school which
were the main social institutions. Today people develop their own
religious and life oriented meanings from different media and from
other sources that are available to them. In this market of meanings,
a few questions arise: How are Christian meanings shared? What
kind of meanings that the people can choose? How can the church
use those means and methods to effectively communicate their own
meanings? What are the impacts some of these mediated meanings
make? What are the alternative ways of communicating Christian
meanings? How can we educate Congregation to select the meanings
that are relevant to them? In what ways can we listen to some of
the serious questions raised to our faith by media? This book will
not try to answer these questions but will certainly engage with these
questions using examples and cases from different media.
My question is how imagination, aesthetic elements, representation,
contemporary audio visuals and interactive characteristics of the
media provide a hermeneutic framework within which audience
fi nding their own meanings of God and of life. The word media can
also include a wide range of means and methods of communication
from a tract to television and also from newspapers to the internet.
In this book, I have selected only those media that have changed
the context of religious thinking or are popular in the public arena
such as fi lms, television, newspapers, and Internet and community
media. The purpose of this book is to mainly highlight the changing
trends of the people’s search for meanings of God and of life in which
media personnel engage, by displaying a wide range of theological
narratives for the public.
The question of imagination in the public display of religious text
today has to be taken seriously by theologians. Frequently, people
use imagination to develop new or old imageries of faith to search
for meanings that are relevant to their context. My fi rst chapter will
deal with the role of imagination in the interaction between media and
theology. Films such as The Da Vinci Code (2006) and The Passion of
7
Searching God in the Media Market
the Christ (2004) differ in the construction of plot and in the imaginative
presentation of the story. The story in The Passion of the Christ Film
exaggerates the suffering of Jesus before and during crucifi xion. The
story follows the New Testament stories to much extent. In this sense
it follows the accepted version of the Biblical passion narratives.
The director also uses contemporary audio and video effects on the
display and agony of the suffering. The imagination of the audience is
infl uenced by such extraordinary visual and audio effects.
The way Jesus gets up after fl ogging is similar to a world wrestling
Federation fi ghter getting up for another round of fi ght. The role of
imagination in such embellished fi lm stories in order to bring the
story alive but exaggerated to fi t into the contemporary fi lm viewing
audience whereby it provides a new hermeneutics using aesthetic
elements, imagination and fi lm art to relate story to meet both the
expectations of the contemporary audience and also thus remain the
public domain as a popular but controversial movie.
In the fi lm The Da Vinci Code the story does not follow the New
Testament narratives about Jesus though it discusses about the secret
code of the art that describes about the last supper of Jesus with his
disciples. In this way the hermeneutic role of imagination is different
from that of other fi lms that follow the New Testament stories closely.
Though the story of Da Vinci provides an entirely different narrative
to imagine, this story too provides a public display of Christian
tradition, images and stories which are somewhat deviant from that
of the New Testament stories or traditional stories. In this sense both
fi lms being taken as examples provide a challenge for theologians
to think about the role of imagination and the use of contemporary
images in doing hermeneutics of the Biblical and traditional stories.
Rather than neglecting these stories as a mere non-historical and pure
entertainment stories, those who are involved in doing hermeneutics
need to look at them and possibly identify the hermeneutic methods
and explore whether a systematic theological method for interpreting
gospel stories to the public audience today. These fi lms interpret and
challenge the meanings that arise out of the biblical stories in a new
John Joshva Raja
8
way that may contribute to the faith and worldview of the audience.
The relationship between revelation, imagination and imageries/
images has not been systematically studied in the visuals of the
modern media, particularly in fi lms. McIntyre’s book on Theology
and Imagination, (1987) is a good book but it does not consider the
Eastern perspectives where the imaginary visual world and the real
world often converge and are often considered the same in the mind of
the audience. This will be discussed in the fi rst chapter. Scholars such
as Gordon Kaufmann, David Tracy and Sally McFague have discussed
the role of imagination in relation to theology but in relation to media
and theology, such discussions have yet to happen. The imaginary
world that is created by the media provides a wide range of meanings
of faith enabling the audience to search for their own meanings and
choose them according to their own interest. Theology has to take
very seriously the public role of imagination and its relationship to
the faith that is displayed in the public. This chapter will discuss the
role of imagination in the interaction between media and theology,
particularly how imagination plays in the meaning making process of
the audience from the text.
The second chapter will deal with the role of entertainment in
the interaction between theology and media. It will look at the way
tele-gurus play gods in television’s various channels. They tend to
fi x narratives, God and their version of the gospel and package and
sell it in the media market. These tele-gurus with their commercial
theologies try to entertain, promise and exploit the audience’s
economic, psychological and physical weakness. The beauty and
other elements of entertainment using the technologies and skills of
television camera persons attract, popularize and sell the packaged
gospel to the public through the media. Such tele-gurus popularize
tele-gods to the public through miracles and performance and thus
create a public space for themselves. This provides a challenge for
theological studies by raising questions about the role of entertainment
and leisure in theology. Many scholars such as Stewart Hoover, Peter
Horsfi eld and others have studied tele-evangelists in the United States
9
Searching God in the Media Market
and have contributed to this area. This chapter will focus not only
on the tele-evangelists but also the tele-gurus such as Nameologists
(luck with names), Numerologists (prediction with birthdates),
Astrologists, Signaterologists (changing future with signature) and
Vastuologists (house square and luck calculations). These tele-gurus
with their different ‘logism’ present a great challenge to theological
thinking. This will be discussed in this chapter with a special emphasis
on theology of religious entertainment and religious leisure.
My third chapter deals with the misrepresentation of various
sections of the minorities such as religious and ethnic minorities,
women, differently-able persons and HIV infected individuals. This
raises a new issue in the area of theology of mission to the public.
In displaying not only the minorities but also ‘the other’, mass
media professionals seem to have used a kind of dualistic approach
in which the outsider or the other is often shown with a negative or
a stereotypical connotation to their character or culture. They use
different colours, images and words to refl ect and reiterate the known
stereotypical concepts about the other that the audience also share.
In this way old imageries and their meanings such as darkness and
blackness converge with meanings of social evil and negative roles
in the stories. This often creates articulate ignorance about ‘the other’
and provides a misrepresentation in the public. In order to respond
to the issues of freedom of expression, culture of ignorance, culture
of confrontation and violence, one needs to theologically respond
to the issues of ‘misrepresentation’ and ‘less representation’. Some
newspapers particularly popularize negative images about other
communities and other persons within the communities. To some
extent such repeated stereotypical images in the public create a
culture of ignorance in the mind set of the majority and creates a lot
of tension within families, communities and nations. Such ignorance
between communities often leads to confrontation and violence.
In such a context theology needs to be challenged in order to
address the issue of community representation and thus to remove
the ignorance among communities and to establish relationship
John Joshva Raja
10
and understanding among them. The questions of ‘other’ and the
stereotypical imageries in the media and theology will also be raised
in this chapter. In this context, I will refer to Huntington’s thesis of
the ‘Clash of Civilizations’ and the review of this thesis by Edward
Said. The search for meanings of ‘other’ and the deconstruction
of stereotypical images are part of the ongoing process of every
community. Through this process, media personal and audience
interact to fi nd their own and relevant meanings.
The fourth chapter will deal with the internet and theology.
According to the Lycos1 search engine, the second most searched
subject on the internet, besides sex, is God. It is a challenge for
theologians to recognize and engage in such searches for meanings of
God and of life in the media along with the audience.
The internet provides a new way of communication that is
interactive and creates a new space for the younger generation
to search for self, God and anything else they may want
according to their interest and tastes. It is a fast, hypertext-based,
audience-centred, mainly secret and cheap means of communication.
On the internet, many are engaged in attempting to build and break
their relationship and search for meanings of God and of life. On
the internet, the virtual self searches for a virtual God where one
may discover or destroy one’s own faith. This changing paradigm
of communication challenges the way in which communication is
understood in traditional terms by theologians. This demands us to
re-vision the question of God itself as an interactive communicator
with people. The relevant questions are: does God himself change
according to the changes in the world? Or is what changes our
interpretation of God in the light of these changes to the world as we
experience it, our theology? To this end, Frances Plude’s interactive
method will be analyzed from a theological perspective.
The internet provides a huge range of means to search for meanings
of God and of life according to one’s own expectation and personal
interest. This shifts the quest from a theo-centric to a human-centric
approach to theological paradigms. Thomas Thangaraj [1999:1–7]
11
Searching God in the Media Market
in his book, The Common Task: A Theology of Christian Mission,
demands a paradigm shift in doing mission in which we need to
emphasize the ‘missio-humanitatis’,, the mission of humankind rather
than the ‘missio-Dei’, the mission of God. This provides a platform
for re-visioning the image of God as a participatory, interactive and
dynamic person. This chapter will discuss how the understanding of
God is being infl uenced by the way the culture of communication has
emerged through the internet.
Community media have emerged as counter media to the
mainstream media in the developing countries but not many have
taken their religious roles seriously. They enable people to organize
themselves and to express their concerns among themselves and with
others. This has brought radical social changes using folk, alternative
and technological media. Community media are readily available,
accessible and affordable by the people. Among many communities
this has brought radical changes in terms of social, economic and
political enlightenment and awareness to the people at the margins.
From simple chalkboards to news media, these media are making a
marked impact on people’s religious faith. People have increasingly
become critical of the religious institutions and their leaders through
such media. Our question is to search for the theological response
to such media practices and to assess their impact on those who use
them.
The mass media play the role of informer, educator and entertainer
whereas community media interact with communities in their search
for religious meanings or to engage the communities themselves in
such searches. Theologically we are invited to develop a concept of
God who is also communitarian in nature. Maintaining communitarian
values does not mean losing the freedom of individuals, rather
fi nding a negotiated space for individual freedom and creativity
and maintaining the positive role of certain agreed values within a
particular community. Such a theological framework would also
enable future theologians to discover God in their respective ways.
This chapter will also deal with Habermas’ quest for rediscovering
John Joshva Raja
12
Media towers were taller than the towers of the churches and
thereby symbolically replaced the power of infl uencing public faith,
values and attitude to much extent. Institutions such as churches,
schools and families had once been dominant sources of providing
meanings of life and of God [Goethals, 1990] but today the media
compete with these as dominant sources of meanings and provide a
market of meanings from which people buy and borrow meanings
that satisfy them in their changing contexts. The changing contexts
demand people to search for meanings of God and of life. Among the
competing social, cultural and political institutions, media has taken
the central role in communicating these meanings to the public and
enabling them to share through them as well. Engaging in such search
for meanings of life and of God, led media to play the role of a pastor,
theologian, prophet and educator in public and private lives of people.
When the audience construct and negotiate their meanings of God
and of life there begins the dialogue between theology and media.
This book is an attempt to provide a space for dialogue between
theology and media from new directions and especially dialogue
between perspectives from the South and North. It is diffi cult to
address all the issues and questions related to this area within so slim
a book and so inevitably some choices had to be made. This book will
focus on those issues that are often neglected by the media scholars
in relation to religion and also by theological scholars in relation to
media such as imagination, entertainment, representation, freedom
and alternatives. The media have created irreversible contexts where
many new questions arise for theological thinking and studies. The
primary principle of this book is to show that theologians have to take
media seriously in their contextualising hermeneutics and particularly
in addressing some question being raised by people after their
encounter with media. Hermeneutics involves developing meanings
John Joshva Raja
6
of those narratives about God and about life in the universe. These
meanings were once provided by the church, family and school which
were the main social institutions. Today people develop their own
religious and life oriented meanings from different media and from
other sources that are available to them. In this market of meanings,
a few questions arise: How are Christian meanings shared? What
kind of meanings that the people can choose? How can the church
use those means and methods to effectively communicate their own
meanings? What are the impacts some of these mediated meanings
make? What are the alternative ways of communicating Christian
meanings? How can we educate Congregation to select the meanings
that are relevant to them? In what ways can we listen to some of
the serious questions raised to our faith by media? This book will
not try to answer these questions but will certainly engage with these
questions using examples and cases from different media.
My question is how imagination, aesthetic elements, representation,
contemporary audio visuals and interactive characteristics of the
media provide a hermeneutic framework within which audience
fi nding their own meanings of God and of life. The word media can
also include a wide range of means and methods of communication
from a tract to television and also from newspapers to the internet.
In this book, I have selected only those media that have changed
the context of religious thinking or are popular in the public arena
such as fi lms, television, newspapers, and Internet and community
media. The purpose of this book is to mainly highlight the changing
trends of the people’s search for meanings of God and of life in which
media personnel engage, by displaying a wide range of theological
narratives for the public.
The question of imagination in the public display of religious text
today has to be taken seriously by theologians. Frequently, people
use imagination to develop new or old imageries of faith to search
for meanings that are relevant to their context. My fi rst chapter will
deal with the role of imagination in the interaction between media and
theology. Films such as The Da Vinci Code (2006) and The Passion of
7
Searching God in the Media Market
the Christ (2004) differ in the construction of plot and in the imaginative
presentation of the story. The story in The Passion of the Christ Film
exaggerates the suffering of Jesus before and during crucifi xion. The
story follows the New Testament stories to much extent. In this sense
it follows the accepted version of the Biblical passion narratives.
The director also uses contemporary audio and video effects on the
display and agony of the suffering. The imagination of the audience is
infl uenced by such extraordinary visual and audio effects.
The way Jesus gets up after fl ogging is similar to a world wrestling
Federation fi ghter getting up for another round of fi ght. The role of
imagination in such embellished fi lm stories in order to bring the
story alive but exaggerated to fi t into the contemporary fi lm viewing
audience whereby it provides a new hermeneutics using aesthetic
elements, imagination and fi lm art to relate story to meet both the
expectations of the contemporary audience and also thus remain the
public domain as a popular but controversial movie.
In the fi lm The Da Vinci Code the story does not follow the New
Testament narratives about Jesus though it discusses about the secret
code of the art that describes about the last supper of Jesus with his
disciples. In this way the hermeneutic role of imagination is different
from that of other fi lms that follow the New Testament stories closely.
Though the story of Da Vinci provides an entirely different narrative
to imagine, this story too provides a public display of Christian
tradition, images and stories which are somewhat deviant from that
of the New Testament stories or traditional stories. In this sense both
fi lms being taken as examples provide a challenge for theologians
to think about the role of imagination and the use of contemporary
images in doing hermeneutics of the Biblical and traditional stories.
Rather than neglecting these stories as a mere non-historical and pure
entertainment stories, those who are involved in doing hermeneutics
need to look at them and possibly identify the hermeneutic methods
and explore whether a systematic theological method for interpreting
gospel stories to the public audience today. These fi lms interpret and
challenge the meanings that arise out of the biblical stories in a new
John Joshva Raja
8
way that may contribute to the faith and worldview of the audience.
The relationship between revelation, imagination and imageries/
images has not been systematically studied in the visuals of the
modern media, particularly in fi lms. McIntyre’s book on Theology
and Imagination, (1987) is a good book but it does not consider the
Eastern perspectives where the imaginary visual world and the real
world often converge and are often considered the same in the mind of
the audience. This will be discussed in the fi rst chapter. Scholars such
as Gordon Kaufmann, David Tracy and Sally McFague have discussed
the role of imagination in relation to theology but in relation to media
and theology, such discussions have yet to happen. The imaginary
world that is created by the media provides a wide range of meanings
of faith enabling the audience to search for their own meanings and
choose them according to their own interest. Theology has to take
very seriously the public role of imagination and its relationship to
the faith that is displayed in the public. This chapter will discuss the
role of imagination in the interaction between media and theology,
particularly how imagination plays in the meaning making process of
the audience from the text.
The second chapter will deal with the role of entertainment in
the interaction between theology and media. It will look at the way
tele-gurus play gods in television’s various channels. They tend to
fi x narratives, God and their version of the gospel and package and
sell it in the media market. These tele-gurus with their commercial
theologies try to entertain, promise and exploit the audience’s
economic, psychological and physical weakness. The beauty and
other elements of entertainment using the technologies and skills of
television camera persons attract, popularize and sell the packaged
gospel to the public through the media. Such tele-gurus popularize
tele-gods to the public through miracles and performance and thus
create a public space for themselves. This provides a challenge for
theological studies by raising questions about the role of entertainment
and leisure in theology. Many scholars such as Stewart Hoover, Peter
Horsfi eld and others have studied tele-evangelists in the United States
9
Searching God in the Media Market
and have contributed to this area. This chapter will focus not only
on the tele-evangelists but also the tele-gurus such as Nameologists
(luck with names), Numerologists (prediction with birthdates),
Astrologists, Signaterologists (changing future with signature) and
Vastuologists (house square and luck calculations). These tele-gurus
with their different ‘logism’ present a great challenge to theological
thinking. This will be discussed in this chapter with a special emphasis
on theology of religious entertainment and religious leisure.
My third chapter deals with the misrepresentation of various
sections of the minorities such as religious and ethnic minorities,
women, differently-able persons and HIV infected individuals. This
raises a new issue in the area of theology of mission to the public.
In displaying not only the minorities but also ‘the other’, mass
media professionals seem to have used a kind of dualistic approach
in which the outsider or the other is often shown with a negative or
a stereotypical connotation to their character or culture. They use
different colours, images and words to refl ect and reiterate the known
stereotypical concepts about the other that the audience also share.
In this way old imageries and their meanings such as darkness and
blackness converge with meanings of social evil and negative roles
in the stories. This often creates articulate ignorance about ‘the other’
and provides a misrepresentation in the public. In order to respond
to the issues of freedom of expression, culture of ignorance, culture
of confrontation and violence, one needs to theologically respond
to the issues of ‘misrepresentation’ and ‘less representation’. Some
newspapers particularly popularize negative images about other
communities and other persons within the communities. To some
extent such repeated stereotypical images in the public create a
culture of ignorance in the mind set of the majority and creates a lot
of tension within families, communities and nations. Such ignorance
between communities often leads to confrontation and violence.
In such a context theology needs to be challenged in order to
address the issue of community representation and thus to remove
the ignorance among communities and to establish relationship
John Joshva Raja
10
and understanding among them. The questions of ‘other’ and the
stereotypical imageries in the media and theology will also be raised
in this chapter. In this context, I will refer to Huntington’s thesis of
the ‘Clash of Civilizations’ and the review of this thesis by Edward
Said. The search for meanings of ‘other’ and the deconstruction
of stereotypical images are part of the ongoing process of every
community. Through this process, media personal and audience
interact to fi nd their own and relevant meanings.
The fourth chapter will deal with the internet and theology.
According to the Lycos1 search engine, the second most searched
subject on the internet, besides sex, is God. It is a challenge for
theologians to recognize and engage in such searches for meanings of
God and of life in the media along with the audience.
The internet provides a new way of communication that is
interactive and creates a new space for the younger generation
to search for self, God and anything else they may want
according to their interest and tastes. It is a fast, hypertext-based,
audience-centred, mainly secret and cheap means of communication.
On the internet, many are engaged in attempting to build and break
their relationship and search for meanings of God and of life. On
the internet, the virtual self searches for a virtual God where one
may discover or destroy one’s own faith. This changing paradigm
of communication challenges the way in which communication is
understood in traditional terms by theologians. This demands us to
re-vision the question of God itself as an interactive communicator
with people. The relevant questions are: does God himself change
according to the changes in the world? Or is what changes our
interpretation of God in the light of these changes to the world as we
experience it, our theology? To this end, Frances Plude’s interactive
method will be analyzed from a theological perspective.
The internet provides a huge range of means to search for meanings
of God and of life according to one’s own expectation and personal
interest. This shifts the quest from a theo-centric to a human-centric
approach to theological paradigms. Thomas Thangaraj [1999:1–7]
11
Searching God in the Media Market
in his book, The Common Task: A Theology of Christian Mission,
demands a paradigm shift in doing mission in which we need to
emphasize the ‘missio-humanitatis’,, the mission of humankind rather
than the ‘missio-Dei’, the mission of God. This provides a platform
for re-visioning the image of God as a participatory, interactive and
dynamic person. This chapter will discuss how the understanding of
God is being infl uenced by the way the culture of communication has
emerged through the internet.
Community media have emerged as counter media to the
mainstream media in the developing countries but not many have
taken their religious roles seriously. They enable people to organize
themselves and to express their concerns among themselves and with
others. This has brought radical social changes using folk, alternative
and technological media. Community media are readily available,
accessible and affordable by the people. Among many communities
this has brought radical changes in terms of social, economic and
political enlightenment and awareness to the people at the margins.
From simple chalkboards to news media, these media are making a
marked impact on people’s religious faith. People have increasingly
become critical of the religious institutions and their leaders through
such media. Our question is to search for the theological response
to such media practices and to assess their impact on those who use
them.
The mass media play the role of informer, educator and entertainer
whereas community media interact with communities in their search
for religious meanings or to engage the communities themselves in
such searches. Theologically we are invited to develop a concept of
God who is also communitarian in nature. Maintaining communitarian
values does not mean losing the freedom of individuals, rather
fi nding a negotiated space for individual freedom and creativity
and maintaining the positive role of certain agreed values within a
particular community. Such a theological framework would also
enable future theologians to discover God in their respective ways.
This chapter will also deal with Habermas’ quest for rediscovering
John Joshva Raja
12
No comments:
Post a Comment